It's time for another in our "Ask Collected Editions" series! On the Collected Editions Facebook page, DC Comics continuity's got Robin Armour all tied in knots. Let's see if we can help.

As always, if you have a question for "Ask Collected Editions," send an email to the Yahoo account or post it on the Collected Editions Facebook wall, and your question could be used in a future segment.

From Robin:
I was wondering if you could answer a long-standing question of mine that's been bugging me on and off for the past couple of years.

In Flash: Secret of Barry Allen and indeed Identity Crisis it is proposed, unless I am very much mistaken, that Barry Allen is the Flash that voted to wipe the memory of Doctor Light and effectively lobotomize him.

I find this a little hard to swallow given that for this to have been in continuity it would had to have happened before Crisis on Infinite Earths, and the DC Universe didn't start getting majorly gritty until after 1986. Up until recently I wasn't even certain if characters were aware of the Crisis or if they had just rebooted the whole continuity, starting the characters all over again -- I thought that was the whole point of Crisis?

I guess the Crisis must have done a bit of retconning because since the event there's been very little coverage of Dick Grayson's years as Robin and that's meant to be pretty early on in the game ...

I think my basic question was did the events in the flashback sequence in Identity Crisis take place before or after Crisis and if after, then how was Barry around to decide to wipe Doctor Light's mind?
I actually think I can answer this.

First, let me confirm that in the flashbacks in Identity Crisis, Barry Allen is indeed the Flash, and Wally West is the Flash in the present. Barry is shown having made the deciding vote to lobotomize Dr. Light at least in part due to the recent death of his wife Iris Allen (later revealed alive).

The Identity Crisis flashbacks are supposed to take place around the same time as Justice League of America #166-168, from the late 1970s. Certainly, DC's titles at that time weren't as "gritty" as Identity Crisis; the book engages in "retroactive continuity," changing elements of a previous story after the fact. Also, one theme of Identity Crisis was to suggest those old, "simpler" stories weren't actually as simple as we might have believed.

Second, part of your confusion can be alleviated by explaining that Crisis on Infinite Earths was a "soft reboot" and not a "hard reboot." The origins of Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman were all revised, but plenty other characters continued with their histories intact -- Wally West, the Teen Titans, the original Hawk and Dove, and the Green Lantern Corps, to name a few. (In this way, the Crisis and Flashpoint reboots are actually somewhat similar.)

All the characters, therefore, remember Barry Allen and know that he died in a "crisis" of sorts, though not necessarily one that involved multiple Earths. Awareness of Crisis would vary from character to character for quite a while until Infinite Crisis, when it was generally accepted that an event had taken place involving the Multiverse, if not that continuity was itself rebooted.

Much of the history of the Justice League remained intact after Crisis, except that where Wonder Woman was a founding member originally, in the post-Crisis continuity Black Canary took her place (as depicted, among other places, in Mark Waid's excellent JLA: Year One, which was essentially accurate until Infinite Crisis restored Wonder Woman's place in the League).

DC would shoe-horn all of this modified League history, Barry Allen's career, Dick Grayson's time as Robin, Don Hall's career as Dove, as so on, into what could be called "the ten-year gap." This is the period after the end of John Byrne's Man of Steel miniseries and prior to Byrne's Superman #1 -- you can essentially shove any pre-Crisis event that's still in continuity in there. Identity Crisis therefore flashes back to issues that were published in the 1970s, but that take place post-Crisis between Man of Steel and Superman #1 continuity-wise. (I believe DC's 1995 "Year One" annual series were also meant to take place in the ten-year gap.)

Again, in this way I think the Crisis on Infinite Earths and Flashpoint reboots are not so different as we might think. Both Crisis and Flashpoint were "soft reboots" that relaunched some but not all of the DC characters, changing some continuities and leaving others somewhat intact. Crisis and Flashpoint also have built-in gaps to encompass material from previous continuities; for Crisis it was the ten-year gap, and for Flashpoint it's the five-year gap between the first arc of Justice League and the second.

Hope that helps! Remember, if you have a question, don't hesitate to drop me a line, and your question could be featured next time in "Ask Collected Editions." Thanks!

Jet Powers answers the call, from President Truman no less, to find the source of the mysterious earthquakes that are leveling cities. Truman doesn't send his intelligence services, the FBI, the Army or Marines, he sends one guy who spends his time working in a lonely mesa laboratory.

Jet, a creation of Gardner Fox for ME Comics, easily finds the cause (the story is only ten pages, after all), and a pretty Asian girl, along with a sinister villain called Mr. Sinn. If ever there was a name for a villain, Mr. Sinn is it.

I've shown this story before, in the earliest days of Pappy's, but it's time to show it again with new scans. It's drawn by an all-time favorite of mine, Bob Powell, who is well represented here over the past six years. Click on his name in the tags below for more Powell.

From Jet #1, actually called A-1 #30 in the indicia (1950):










"Professor H" (Henry Kujawa) has beautiful restorations of the covers of Jet numbers 1-4 here.
Legion of Super-Heroes: Consequences is a fine next chapter in Paul Levitz's ongoing Legion saga. I use the word "saga" specifically here, because indeed Levitz seems to be writing a Legion opus, as he's done before, that pays no real mind to the structures of issue nor collection. Consequences picks up some threads from the previous volume The Choice and entirely overlooks others; it also ends very suddenly, underlining that where the collection ends was not so much foremost in the mind of the author. It does not help the vague nature of this collection that in the hardcover, at least, some of the chapters are printed out of order.

The Legion of Super-Heroes titles remain at the top of my reading list, but Consequences is the kind of Legion collection that reinforces how much dedication it takes to be a Legion fan. You must be really invested to read a collection that follows these characters but bears little connection to the previous book. Consequences will leave ardent Legion fans hungry for the next volume, but I wonder if with this one we'll lose some of those that were on the fence.

[Contains spoilers]

Consequences's driving story is of a plot by shapeshifting Durlans to assassinate members of the United Planets council. Levitz portrays this well, and what could have been a run-of-the-mill conspiracy story becomes a mystery with a nice twist at the end. We have seen plenty of multi-species wars in the Legion titles before; it's actually refreshing that this turns out to be a more basic crime story than another lofty tale among others.

Long-time Legion fans will find much to enjoy in this one. Not only does Chameleon Boy specifically call out to his last trip to Durla before this book -- an adventure published almost twenty years ago in one of Levitz's earlier runs on Legion -- but Levitz's approach to the Legion hasn't much changed either. Cosmic Boy is tired of being Legion leader just as Lightning Lad and Element Boy were in Levitz's Great Darkness and The Curse from the 1980s; Consequences features an in medias res Legion leader election just like Levitz's old stories do. Levitz has a very specific formula for how the Legion works which has lasted him well for a while and he does not deviate from it here, if you like that sort of thing.

The story shines in Levitz's depiction of Chameleon Boy and also of Brainiac 5, who's brilliant and witty and sarcastic and caring all in one (there's never been a Brainiac 5 miniseries? Really?). Levitz also portrays an interestingly moody Mon-El, the thirty-first century's new Green Lantern. Mon-El's recent angst has been hard to place given that we didn't see he and Shadow Lass's divorce onscreen, but the scene where Shady talks about how Mon-El changed since his newest imprisonment in the Phantom Zone goes a long way toward explaining it. The story's inference that Mon-El was perhaps destined to be a Lantern is fascinating, and I enjoy this subplot even if it does seem slightly to pander to the Green Lantern title's current success.

I was struck, however, by how much Consequences doesn't cover. The Durlan B-plot from Choice becomes Levitz's A-plot here, but Lightning Lad and Saturn Girl's struggles with Darkseid's minions from Choice barely warrants a mention. We don't see Blok and the White Witch at all, nor much of controversial new Legionnaire Earth-Man or the Legion Academy. Choice's cliffhanger dealt with time-travelling professor Harmonia Li, but surprisingly Levitz clarifies Li's origins almost not at all.

I refer to the "A" and "B" plots also specifically; Levitz did not necessarily create this way of writing serialized fiction where a B-plot starts small and rises to the surface, but he has championed what's called the "Levitz paradigm". It ought not be much of a surprise then that the Legion title is functioning this way, but some may find it unsettling in this landscape of one-hero-one-story titles.

The real impediment to Consequences's easy reading, however, is that I believe DC has presented the issues collected here in the wrong order. The book starts with the Legion of Super-Heroes Annual #1, which refers to "the Durlan crisis" even though the characters don't actually find out about it until Legion #7, which is presented second. Adventure Comics #521 is next, followed by Adventure #522 and then Legion #8, but Legion #8 should be between the two Adventure issues because they find out about a specific Durlan impostor in #8 and then refer to it in #522; otherwise the reader will think "How did they know that?"

A well-versed reader like me can figure it out, but it did confuse me for a moment; and an uninitiated reader might very well set the book aside for this kind of thing. It's one thing to tie up a reader in a mystery, but a reader having to translate the correct order of chapters is another thing entirely. This is obviously a mistake by the DC collections team, one harder to catch because it involves two titles instead of just printing two issues of the Teen Titans series out of order.  I emailed DC collections editor Ian Sattler about it to maybe get it fixed in the paperback, but so far I haven't heard back.

These issues aside, the space soap opera continues, and having spent the last two weeks reading and reviewing Legion of Super-Heroes comics, all I can say is that I want more! It's a pleasure to have Paul Levitz back on Legion and it's obvious he cares about these characters, and I'm eager to see what he does with them in the DC New 52. For now, Legion: Consequences will have to tide you over until Legion: When Evil Calls comes around.

[Includes original covers, extras from Legion annual. Printed on glossy paper]

Green Lantern reviews and more, right here next week.
[Guest review by Doug Glassman]

Similar to the last volume, My Monsters, Invincible Iron Man: Unfixable puts the title in a holding pattern between the Heroic Age and Fear Itself. However, Unfixable does have what that volume lacked: a great core story for the majority of the book.

As indicated on the cover, Iron Man’s foe is Doctor Octopus. Yes, that’s Doc Ock. His new look was explained in Amazing Spider-Man as being caused by his body failing due to his various battles. This makes a lot of sense: after all, Doc Ock has never been the most physically fit of villains, and his arms are directly connected to his spine, which can’t be good for either his nervous system or his skeleton.

Doc Ock now wields eight tentacles and operates from what can best be described as a mixture between Brainiac’s skull ship from the 1980s and a pistachio nut. Notably, his face is covered except for his eyes; is this so they can retcon him away later as not being Otto Octavius?

I truly hope not, because the clash between Stark and Octavius is a clever one, going back to Tony’s pre-Iron Man days. While Octavius respected the boundaries placed on him by his financiers, Stark was a “science hippie,” always trying out new concepts ... and getting alcoholic blackouts when they failed. It’s great that Matt Fraction created a conflict between two long-existing characters rather than coming up with a new rival for Stark out of nowhere. The Hammers and Stanes of the world are fine enough foes without having yet another “lifelong competitor” like the bland Tiberius Stone showing up.

With so many other things going on in his mind -- the Mandarin, the Avengers, his work -- Tony clearly considers Ock to be less than important. Throughout the three-issue story, much of it is spent with them bickering at each other over minor matters that have been escalated into a nuclear threat. The Sandman and Electro make entertaining cameos, representing the recently reunited Sinister Six; their foe in this story is Pepper Potts, now augmented with her own arc reactor as Rescue.

While giving powers to non-powered side characters can be a mistake (see Jimmy Olsen and Snapper Carr for two DC examples, or Rick Jones for a Marvel one), Pepper is able to differentiate herself from Iron Man and War Machine through her non-violent mission. Her weaponless suit is designed to help victims, not hurt criminals. In her fight against two of the most powerful villains in Spider-Man’s rogues, she has to push beyond her boundaries. The book ends somewhat abruptly with the start of Fear Itself in New York, but considering how Invincible Iron Man has close ties to that event, it’s not surprising.

The other two stories in Unfixable, while serving to pad out the trade, also reinforce some of the main story’s theme. The FCBD story is part of Iron Man’s reconciliation with Thor, who you may recall had a tense encounter with Iron Man all the way back in The Five Nightmares. In the wake of Siege, Tony’s struggling new business has been handed to contract to rebuild Asgard and Broxton. However, this story is set slightly beforehand, where a group of rich moon-dwellers has built a weather domination machine from some of Tony’s old plans. These villains steal the show, attempting to form a Randian utopia in the mold of Rapture from Bioshock. Their comeuppance is swift, and it’s a good background for the healing process of two founding Avengers.

After this comes the Rescue one-shot, which plunges us right into the heart of Dark Reign yet again. One of the silliest conceits during Rescue’s debut is that Norman Osborn would only let Pepper use the armor for about half an hour before sending HAMMER forces out to capture her. Now, the Green Goblin was never all there, but this was one of the most ridiculous things I’ve ever seen him do. The countdown timer, while a reference to 24, now reminds me more of Tokumei Sentai Go-Busters, which uses a clock in the corner of the screen to count down until the giant monster’s arrival.

Kelly Sue DeConnick (married to Matt Fraction) does her best with what she’s given, and focuses the story around an exhausted Pepper conversing with her dead husband, Happy Hogan. Thanks to the movies and other adaptations, their marriage has faded from readers’ memory, so it’s good to see that Pepper still thinks about him. It’s a simple story, but Pepper Potts is a character due for a solo issue.

The main story’s art is once again provided by Salvador Larroca and his colorist Frank D’armata (thanks for the comments correcting me that he does colors, not inks). I love how the colors and inks fade for the flashback segments.

Because I skipped reviewing Stark Resilient, this is my chance to talk about Iron Man’s new armor. While it goes a little overboard with the various light ports, it’s otherwise a gorgeous design, officially known as the Bleeding Edge armor. Any merchandising calling it the “Modular Armor” is dead wrong -- the Modular Armor was introduced in Iron Man Col. 1 #300 and was the inspiration for the armors used in the 1994 animated series and Marvel vs. Capcom. Iron Man fans take the model numbers, names and incarnations very seriously.

John Romita, Jr. drew the FCBD story, and despite his occasional tendency to draw square heads, it’s always good to see his art. One panel I especially like is Thor standing confused amidst a storm of raining frogs. The expression on his face is grim: after all, some of Thor’s best friends are frogs. (The Central Park Frogs’ cameo in the Onslaught event was one of the saving graces of having the Avengers shuffled off to another dimension.) As is usually the case with JRJR, industry legend Klaus Janson provides heavy inks.

Andrea Mutti is the artist for the Rescue story, and while the art isn’t bad, it doesn’t fare well being in the same book with Salvador Larroca and JRJR. One notable complaint is that Pepper’s hair color seems to change constantly, appearing bubblegum pink at points. Additionally, the cover for that issue overuses shadows on Pepper’s face, making it look like she has a mustache.

While inessential, much like the book before it, Invincible Iron Man: Unfixable is a much better book thanks to some better story delineation. Instead of an anthology, it has a core story and two back-ups which reinforce it. This book is especially good for Spider-Man fans thanks to its main villains.

Number 1126


Superduper-Gookum!


I've heard the first couple of issues of Mad didn't exactly set the comic book buying world on fire. It took a couple more issues for that to happen, and eventually the comic book was selling a million copies an issue. "Blob" from issue #1, and "Gookum" from #2, both by Wood, didn't get the attention of his later strips, like "Superduperman."

To show some of the difference in the respect "Gookum" got as opposed to "Superduperman," in issue #4 (where Mad sales were said to have taken off), Heritage Auctions sold the six pages of original art for "Gookum" in 2002 for $10,925, but in 2009 the splash page only of "Superduperman" went for $43,318.75.

Above is the scan of the original art for the "Superduperman" splash page, and below the whole six-page "Gookum" for you to look at and admire. There's nothing wrong with "Gookum." The earliest issues of Mad were supposedly take-offs on the EC line, so Wood did science fiction stories and Davis did horror spoofs. It was when Mad started spoofing other comic books and television that readers found them.

I was too young to buy those issues of Mad from the stands, but my brother-in-law, Jim, was a high school kid at the time and said Mad was IT, the coolest comic ever. Even in the early '50s comic books were considered kid stuff, beneath the hep kats in high school, except for Mad.

I'm also showing the color version of "Gookum," which I scanned from the Tales Calculated To Drive You Mad Special #1, published in 1997.













**********
While we're on the subject of EC Comics, I came across this interesting reference to the infamous "Are You A Red Dupe?" ad that ran in EC's titles in mid-1954.

This letter, by T. Bernard Mathews of Reading, PA, was published in the Reading Eagle of May 19, 1954. What Mathews has done is quote directly from the "Red Dupe" ad. (He even perpetuated the misspelling of Wertham's name: it's not "Frederick," but Fredric). "After little reading," he claims early on in his letter. Yes, very little! One page, one ad out of a comic book. That's Bernard's research! I'm not saying the information in the EC page is incorrect, although it does seem a bit odd that they blunted their message with a Mad, or more correctly Panic (i.e., the comic poor Melvin printed is Panisky), satire of Russian censorship.

The ad got publisher William M. Gaines in even more trouble with the Senate committee he testified before. People in that era didn't have a sense of humor about being called red dupes.

I found the letter on the blog, Yesterday's Papers, an amazing site by John Adcock. I recommend it highly.
What are the best or most accessible Legion of Super-Heroes collections? If you had to pick the top ten (or so) greatest Legion of Super-Heroes trade paperbacks to read, what would they be? We've tried to answer this question already with Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Flash, and Green Lantern, and Justice League (plus our top ten DC trades with female protagonists); now we're going to give a Legion of Super-Heroes trade reading order a shot.

The Legion is unique in the DC Universe, second only to the New Gods in its own engrained mythology. Batman fights the Joker and sometimes Superman does too, but there's hordes of heroes special just to the Legion, not to mention villains like Nemesis Kid, Dr. Regulus, and Tyr, rarely been seen outside Legion comics.

But despite the characters being set apart in the future, DC has perennially published the Legion title (often even more than one). Creators and stalwart fans thrive on Legion trivia. It's not hard to see why; I am new to Legion fandom, but the tapestry on which the stories are built is so rich, and the universe so engagingly expansive, that I think Legion titles will always have a place on my reading list now.

I am far from a Legion expert -- I'll provide links to some of those at the end of this post, who can likely answer any Legion question you'll ever have, ever -- but I think my new Legion fandom is a benefit in this instance. What follows are suggestions from a new Legion fan, not a seasoned follower, and in that way maybe I can better help those just starting to read about the Legion of Super-Heroes.

To wit, I believe can be entirely caught up with the Legion with just these books, all but two of which published in the last couple years:

* Legion of Super-Heroes: The Great Darkness Saga
* Legion of Super-Heroes: The Curse
* Justice League of America, Vol. 2: The Lightning Saga
* Superman and the Legion of Super-Heroes
* Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds
* DC Comics Presents: Legion of Super-Heroes #2
* Superman: Last Stand of New Krypton Vol. 1
* Superman: Last Stand of New Krypton Vol. 2
* Superboy and the Legion of Super-Heroes: The Early Years
* Legion of Super-Heroes: The Choice
* Legion of Super-Heroes: Consequences
* Legion of Super-Heroes: When Evil Calls

DC New 52

* Legion of Super-Heroes: Hostile World
* Legion Lost: Run From Tomorrow

(Enter sound of true Legion fans weeping for all that I've just skipped over.)

What you have above in Great Darkness and Curse are part of writer Paul Levitz's 1980s run on Legion ("Great Darkness" is considered one of DC's all-time classic stories); the rest are Geoff Johns's post-Infinite Crisis relaunch and Levitz's current modern run on the title. Legion continuity got a little confusing, to say the least, shortly after Great Darkness, but Johns's relaunch preserves Darkness and then picks up fresh from that point. Levitz's The Choice refers back to Darkness also.

If you want to hit the ground running, catch up on the Legion and their major characters and relationships, and be able to read the DC New 52 Legion titles, this is all you need.

But of course, there's so. much. more.

The Golden Age of the Legion

There is a lot of Legion you could read. A lot. That is, there's thirteen Archives editions (with Legion of Super-Heroes Archives Vol. 13 coming out in May). These would take you from the Legion's earliest appearance in 1958's Adventure Comics #247 all the way to Legion stories published in the late 1970s, Paul Levitz's first run on the series, and important adventures too numerous to list, some still in continuity, including the death and resurrection of Lightning Lad, the death of Ferro Lad, the introduction of Brainiac 5 and others, the marriage of Lightning Lad and Saturn Girl, and on, and on.

No kidding, you could read back issues of Legion forever, and it's a testament to the team's popularity that DC has released so many collections. Material from the first nine Archives is also collected in four black-and-white Showcase Presents volumes, plus a special DC Comics Classics Library: The Life and Death of Ferro Lad hardcover (which duplicates some material from Showcases vols. 2 and 3, or Archives vols. 5 and 6).

Legion Post-Crisis on Infinite Earths

* Legion of Super-Heroes: An Eye for an Eye
* Legion of Super-Heroes: The More Things Change
* Superman: The Man of Steel, Vol. 4

DC has released two Legion collections that take place just after Great Darkness and The Curse and just before Crisis on Infinite Earths, Eye for an Eye and The More Things Change. The Legion titles, at this time, had split into Legion and Tales, and the two books only collect the Legion issues, which lessens their readability somewhat, though these are good stories of the Legion versus the Legion of Super-Villains. I'm still hoping DC will release deluxe hardcovers, like Great Darkness, of both the Legion and Tales stories from this era.

Post-Crisis on Infinite Earths, Superman had never been Superboy and therefore wasn't a member of the Legion. DC revised the Legion's history through the machinations of a villain called the Time Trapper, and this collection of the John Byrne-era Superman stories includes Legion issues and a post-Crisis Superman/Legion team-up. Other than this, precious little of the post-Crisis (including Keith Giffen's famous "Five Years Later" Legion and a spin-off Legionnaires title starring back-to-basics Legion clones) has been collected.

Legion Post-Zero Hour

* Legion of Super-Heroes: The Beginning of Tomorrow
* Final Night
* DC Comics Presents: Legion of Super-Heroes #1
* Legion Lost
* The Legion: Foundations
* Teen Titans: The Future is Now

DC rebooted the Legion completely after the Zero Hour crossover (as they maybe should have done after Crisis). Only basically the beginning of this series is collected and the end; the Legion and Legionnaires titles shuttered with the "Legion of the Damned" storyline, and then DC relaunched the franchise (though not the continuity) with the excellent Legion Lost miniseries that followed from "Damned," and then a new series just called Legion. (Maybe two years in, this Legion factored heavily in the Final Night crossover.) The Connor Kent Superboy guest-starred with this Legion in Foundations, a poor riff on Great Darkness Saga, before this Legion was lost in time and the series ended as of the Teen Titans trade.

"Threeboot" Legion

* Legion of Super-Heroes: Teenage Revolution
* Legion of Super-Heroes: Death of a Dream
* Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: Strange Visitor from Another Century
* Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: Adult Education
* Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: The Dominator War
* Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes: The Quest for Cosmic Boy
* Legion of Super-Heroes: Enemy Rising
* Legion of Super-Heroes: Enemy Manifest

Called such because it would be the third from-scratch version of the Legion, the "Threeboot" series was written by Mark Waid with no connection to any previous Legion series. The first volumes, especially, are quite good, and I credit this series with sparking my own interest in the Legion. Waid portrays the Legion as a youthful political movement in a way I hadn't considered the Legion before, and his take is definitely more "space opera" than action series, much like that of Levitz. The final books by classic Legion writer Jim Shooter are also good enough, though Shooter quite famously feuded with DC towards the end and even had his name removed from some issues.

The second and third Legions are interesting and relevant, in that the second interacted with the DCU and Superboy and the third interacted with the post-Crisis Supergirl, but they're not imperative reading if your only goal is to catch-up with the present. All three Legions appear, as the name suggests, in the Legion of Three Worlds series, though the original and current Legion is the most prominent of the three.

Further Legion reading and resources

* Legion of Super-Heroes: 1,050 Years of the Future

* Teenagers from the Future: Essays on the Legion of Super-Heroes

* The Legion Omnicon
* Legion Abstract
* Legion of Substitute Podcasters
* Legion Wiki

Published for the fiftieth anniversary of the Legion, 1,050 Years of the Future collects stories from about every Legion era. The first appearance is in there and the aforementioned death of Lightning Lad story, as well as material from the post-Zero Hour team. The volume came out in 2008, however, so nothing from the "Threeboot" nor Geoff Johns-reboot series.

Teenagers from the Future is a collection of essays on Legion stories and themes, many by popular authors and bloggers around the 'Net (edited by GeniusboyFiremelon and ComicBookResources's Tim Callahan). I've been holding a copy of this on my shelf for a long while until I'm more familiar with the Legion; now that I've read through Great Darkness Saga, it's probably about time to crack it open.

And then there's a brain trust of Legion sites. Back in 2008, Collected Editions crossed over with the Legion Omnicom for a series of trivia questions supporting a week of Legion reviews (thanks Michael!). I've visited/listened to the other sites throughout my reading when I've been trying to figure various things out (Why does White Witch look like that if she's Dream Girl's sister? Who was Andromeda again?) -- check 'em out!

So that's my Legion run-through. Whew! Hopefully that gives new or confused Legion fans a better idea where to start. If you've got additional Legion questions, just ask, and I'll do my best to answer them. And coming up, our review of Legion of Super-Heroes: Consequences.
I liked Geoff Johns's recent Legion "reboot" -- bringing the classic Legion into modern continuity -- and I liked the first volume of Paul Levitz's return to the Legion title. Bridging the stories of those two writers, or so I thought, were a couple of backup tales by Johns from the Adventure Comics series; I was pleased when DC Comics solicited DC Comics Presents: Legion of Super-Heroes #2, collecting those stories.

Unfortunately, what this volume revealed is that Levitz's first new Legion collection, The Choice -- while entertaining -- picks and chooses from Johns's stories, at times outright ignoring them. That's Levitz's prerogative as the Legion writer, but having followed Johns's Legion to this point, the fact that Levitz doesn't sync up leaves some plotlines terribly unresolved.

What follows is different than my usual reviews in that the DC Comics Presents issue (mainly collecting a story called "Long Live the Legion") really contains precious little to cover. Instead, I'm going to look at how the DC Comics Presents issue by Johns and Levitz's The Choice don't quite mesh. I'm approaching it this way because, having previously read Last Stand of New Krypton (the culmination of Johns's Legion saga) and then The Choice without "Long Live the Legion," my assumption was that the discrepancy between those stories was covered in "Long Live"; having now read "Long Live," I see that's not entirely the case.

For the reader like me trying to follow the Johns/Levitz Legion saga in collected form, here's some areas where if you're confused, it's not because you missed something but rather, in some cases, because everything doesn't quite line up.

First, what DC Comics Presents: Legion #2 does offer us. In The Choice, Saturn Girl and husband Lighting Lad (Imra and Garth Ranzz) have been apart while Garth searches for a sibling he never knew. There's no talk of this in Legion of Three Worlds, for instance, but in The Choice Garth has been gone for a while. "Long Live" covers this; there's no great revelations in Garth's chapter of "Long Live," but if you want the sequence of events laid out, the impetus for Garth's search is shown here.

Levitz ignores, however, or at least does not address in Choice, two other parts of the four-part "Long Live the Legion." In the third chapter, Polar Boy and Sun Boy team up to catch a criminal on Polar Boy's home planet; that criminal not only turns over an artifact from the twenty-first century past, but also hints at a Legion of Super-Villains espionage team in the twenty-first century. An interesting possibility, but nothing that alters the characters necessarily, so we'll give Levitz a pass on the fact that he never mentions this one.

The first chapter of "Long Live the Legion," however, watches the crazed Starman Thom Kallor bounce around a bit in the twenty-first century (before returning to his own time after Last Stand of New Krypton) until he meets fellow Legionnaire Tellus and, in the final panels, begs for help locating the lost Dream Girl. Well, the reader will find her ... in the second chapter of Choice, on her home planet of Naltor, not time-lost nor kidnapped as "Long Live the Legion" suggested.

I don't mean to be overly picky; the reader can chalk up Dream Girl's sudden reappearance to a story yet to be told, of course. But I've been following the saga of this Legion over at least five collections written by Johns, in which the Legion slowly reconstitutes and characters are gathered from all over, until all that are still missing are the Legionnaires in Last Stand of New Krypton and then only Dream Girl, the mystery almost solved ... and Levitz just sweeps it under the rug in The Choice. It's disappointing.

The DC Comics Presents issue also contains the first appearance of the Legion, from the original Adventure Comics #247. This is fun in its simplicity, full of innocent Silver Age trickery, and also for the reader to see how much the Legion has changed: here, they're all from Earth, use rocket-packs to fly, and refer to themselves as the Super-Hero Club (Legion fanatics, when did things change over to the modern Legion with rings and such?).

There's also the fourth part of "Long Live the Legion," a story about Blok and White Witch, who were characters I didn't know much about before I read Legion: Great Darkness Saga, but now I like their nontraditional love affair (and how Johns reflects Wildfire and Dawnstar's problems through their trying to help Blok and the Witch). Levitz gives Blok and White Witch one panel in The Choice, so we'll call that a "pass" also.

These story issues aside, constant readers know my gripes with the DC Comics Presents series are also "legion." This book does not include covers, which is a shame because some of these stories appeared in issues with cool Legion-themed variant covers. Also collected here is Action Comics #864, itself a bridge issue between Superman and the Legion and Legion of Three Worlds -- but it's placed in this book after "Long Live the Legion," not beforehand as originally published.

This may leave the casual reader wondering, for instance, why Starman is free in the beginning of this book and in a sanatorium later on instead of vice versa, and the answer is because there's a lack of artfulness to how the issues are collected here. I'm glad to read both "Long Live the Legion" and Action #864, don't get me wrong, but this combined with the lack of covers gives the DC Comics Presents books a kind of "collect it and forget it" feel -- as if simply reprinting these stories is enough in its own right -- that's a little troubling.

We get a Mon-El story, too, that was also collected in one of James Robinson's Mon-El "New Krypton" volumes; don't even get me started on how this same space ought have gone to something never collected rather than reprinting a collected story over again.

Maybe I'm being overly hard on DC Comics Presents: Legion of Super-Heroes #2. I would rather have had the chance to read Adventure Comics's "Long Live the Legion" than not, so for that reason I'm glad DC released this volume; and Paul Levitz's The Choice remains quite enjoyable even if Dream Girl appears out of nowhere. For Legion fans trying to get the whole story, however, just know that all the pieces don't necessarily make a whole.

Tomorrow ... because you demanded it (well, camckinnon at least), the Collected Editions guide to Legion of Super-Heroes. Don't miss it!